The morals vs ethics of a corporate restructure is a controversial topic. Here, we discuss two converse views on a corporate restructure. Just because something may be morally wrong (in one view), doesn’t make it unethical. We briefly touch on why a corporate restructure may be the right choice for a shareholder and some creditors and what ‘burnt’ creditors could do if it is done incorrectly.
Company restructuring is a strategic overhaul aiming to revamp the organisational structure and operations of a business. Its primary purpose is to enhance efficiency, address financial struggles, or adapt to changing market conditions. Often, it involves significant changes in leadership, operations, or ownership structure.
Restructuring creates a spectrum of winners and losers within the business ecosystem. While it can rejuvenate a struggling company, it often impacts stakeholders significantly. Creditors, particularly subcontractors in industries like construction, bear the brunt of financial losses or unpaid debts.
Navigating the ethical landscape during restructuring poses complex challenges. Directors and shareholders must strike a delicate balance between ethical principles and pragmatic business decisions. The ethical dimensions become apparent when deciding between saving jobs and meeting financial obligations to creditors.
Directors hold a pivotal role and face potential personal liability if found to trade recklessly, disregarding statutory obligations. They bear responsibility for steering the company within legal boundaries and ensuring compliance with regulations.
Despite legal provisions allowing directors of failed companies to trade in new entities, these actions often draw moral scrutiny. The ethical implications arise when directors utilise exceptions to continue operations in a new entity, potentially leaving creditors uncompensated.
In the video, Brent Norling gives and example of a recent case which illustrates the critical role of restructuring in preserving jobs and business continuity. By restructuring, shareholders saved approximately $10 million and maintained 90% of the staff roles. This example demonstrates the tangible impact of ethical decision-making in restructuring.
Ethical dilemmas surface prominently in restructuring scenarios, especially concerning the conflict between safeguarding jobs and fulfilling financial obligations to creditors. This balancing act often poses significant moral quandaries for business leaders.
Beyond the traditional route of business closure, exploring alternative solutions becomes imperative. Companies facing insolvency must consider options that preserve the business while addressing the concerns of creditors, finding a delicate balance between legality and ethicality.
Strict adherence to legal guidelines is paramount during restructuring to shield directors from personal exposure to creditors. Ensuring compliance reduces the potential for legal repercussions and upholds ethical standards.
Engaging in open discussions and exploring alternatives can mitigate ethical challenges and complexities. Seeking professional guidance becomes essential for companies navigating the intricate legal and ethical landscape of restructuring.
Company restructuring embodies a labyrinth of legal and ethical complexities. Striking a balance between legal compliance and moral obligations remains a challenging yet necessary aspect of preserving businesses while respecting stakeholders’ rights and interests.
At Norling Law, we are on both sides of corporate restructures. Sometimes we are on the side of the creditors who want to hold the debtors’ director liable. Other times, we assist the directors of the debtor company to undertake a robust restructure of the business that allows the business to continue, whilst some creditors remain unpaid.
Whichever side you are on, we can provide insight. We offer a FREE 30-minute legal consult where we can discuss the issues.
Brent is the Director of Norling Law. He has a wealth of experience in the District Court, High Court, Court of Appeal and Supreme Court. Brent is passionate about negotiating favourable outcomes for his clients and able to implement this in his daily negotiations.
Book a free consultation to get clarity on your options and next steps
We’ve been guiding people through times of uncertainty since 2015. Talk to us for free to see what we can do for you.
